videogame-fantasy-settings-are-staler-than-mouldy-bread-right-away

The upcoming launch of Baldur’s Gate 3 has stuffed my head with ideas of elves and dragons and enchanted swords, all of which I’ve realised I am totally exhausted by. My tolerance for fantasy impressed by European folklore and Tolkien has totally run out, leaving me wishing game builders would delve into weirder locations to search for a brand new muse. 

Baldur’s Gate is, after all, beholden to an present universe, one of the acquainted ones, so these mainstays are inevitable. However the world of Toril, where the Forgotten Realms are located, is without doubt one of the least thrilling places in D&D, particularly when in comparison with the fantastic mess of the planes or the void between worlds that performs host to Spelljammer campaigns. Gimme a few of that cosmic fantasy.

(Picture credit score: Wizards of the Coast)

That mentioned, Larian deserves credit score for nonetheless embracing the odder aspect of D&D. The deal with thoughts flayers and physique horror, the introduction of characters like The Darkish Urge and, after all, having intercourse with a druid utilizing the Wild Form spell be certain that Baldur’s Gate 3 stands out. The studio is clearly having numerous enjoyable inside this in any other case typical setting and making an attempt to push it in uncommon instructions. However we’re nonetheless inundated with the overly acquainted, where even essentially the most celebrated of fantasy video games really feel obstinately conservative, ticking off a dizzying array of historical tropes.

Conventional fantasy is not inherently shit. I am all the time going to be keen on dwarves, and never simply because they’re continuously introduced as Scottish. It is simply that so many video games, movies and books find yourself retelling the identical tales—ones as previous as Lord of the Rings, which itself owes an enormous debt to folklore. Their impression has been dramatically lessened by oversaturation and an overzealous fixation on racial traits: elves are haughty, dwarves are taciturn and grasping, orcs are dangerous and dumb. This makes even new tales appear staid and predictable. 

It is one of many causes I nonetheless cling to Morrowind, a land where folks reside inside carapaces in a volcanic desert, where wizards fall from the sky, and where public transport is dominated by massive, lovely bugs. And it is proof that you simply needn’t toss out each single acquainted aspect simply to make a spot really feel alien. You have nonetheless acquired your prophecies, a number of a number of elves, colleges of magic—but it surely by no means stops being delightfully bizarre. Thoughts you, eliminating a few of these issues would nonetheless be welcome. 

(Picture credit score: Bethesda)

Sadly, Bethesda ended up entering into the wrong way. When it adopted up Morrowind with Oblivion (a giant European forest) and Skyrim (Scandinavia) I did not abruptly kick the sequence to the curb, however my enthusiasm for exploring these places by no means reached the heights of my journey by their predecessor. I might seen the sunshine, and generic fantasy ceased to drift my boat. 

I might seen the sunshine, and generic fantasy ceased to drift my boat.

For these searching for a mixture of basic fantasy and many novelties, Shadowrun has loads to supply. This tabletop setting, which has impressed a wide range of videogames, together with the wonderful Shadowrun: Dragonfall and Shadowrun: Hong Kong, splices city fantasy with elves and orcs. Large companies run the show, however they exist in a world where magic may be very actual and where they could be hacked by a cybernetically enhanced dwarf. This mix of cyberpunk and conventional fantasy ends in a novel concoction with loads of surprises effervescent to the floor.

Much more than sci-fi, fantasy permits creators to eschew the principles of actuality, where something could make sense in case you give it sufficient context. However it usually looks like builders wish to make fantasy settings much more acquainted, encapsulated by the pattern of tackling points affecting the true world, like how the plight of Dragon Age’s elves mirrors real-world bigotry and colonialism.

Now, fantasy has all the time had one thing to say about actual points—like Lord of the Rings’ critique of industrialisation—and that should not cease. This type of grounding may help us extra simply make sense of those fictional locations. However when it is mixed with so many different tropes, it leaves me determined for some escapism.

(Picture credit score: Failbetter Video games)

Failbetter’s Fallen London setting, which spawned Sunless Sea and Sunless Skies, is probably my favorite instance of a world that strikes the proper stability between the acquainted and the alien. It has all the trimmings of Victorian London, however a Victorian London that was dragged beneath the bottom by bats, which sits subsequent door to Hell, where devils had been as soon as bees. It’s, always, unhinged and shocking, now boasting a number of video games filled with indescribable horrors and oddities. And its model of horror is novel, too, wanting past the same old sources of inspiration.

As an alternative of elves casting spells, you’ve got acquired scarab-headed girls making artwork out of fruit and saliva.

At a time when Lovecraft is a touchstone for thus many videogames, Failbetter as an alternative appears to writers like China Mieville, whose bizarre tales are much more weird and unsettling, however with out the pervasive racism. I used to be rereading Mieville’s Perdido Road Station just lately and there is nonetheless nothing prefer it. As an alternative of elves casting spells, you’ve got acquired scarab-headed girls making artwork out of fruit and saliva, murderous betentacled moths who can get you excessive from their excrement and a canine possessed by a sentient hand. With each chapter there’s one thing new to wrap your head round, however hardly ever does it ever get too baffling.

That, I think, is a concern builders have when crafting a setting: “If we go too bizarre, will gamers simply get confused?” For the likes of BioWare and Bethesda particularly, they’re focused on one thing with a broad enchantment. If you enter a world closely impressed by previous fantasy tropes, you instantly perceive it. As an alternative of spending ages swotting up on esoteric lore, you’ll be able to simply begin stabbing stuff along with your enchanted sword. However I am satisfied builders can have their cake and eat it too.

(Picture credit score: Tyler C. / FromSoftware)

Simply have a look at the success of Elden Ring, a game where the narrative is something however specific and also you make associates with a heroic jar filled with blood/wine/no matter that’s. Now it is baffling, however that did not cease an enormous variety of folks from changing into completely obsessive about it. There’s not simply house for the bizarre, there is a starvation for it.

It is not simply extra oddities that I desperately need, although. It is new experiences. On the very least, it is about time for extra fantasy video games to depart Europe behind. The nicely of European folklore has nicely and really run dry. That is why I am enthusiastic about The Wagadu Chronicles, an afrofantasy MMO impressed by African mythology. And it is intriguing past the setting, promising a world where gamers are absolutely in management, even enjoying the function of NPCs with emergent quests.

The Wagadu Chronicles is just not alone in shining a lightweight on the folklore of different locations, however this activity is generally left to smaller, unbiased studios who do not have the finances to spend on big advertising campaigns and possibly will not ever get launched on stage by the likes of Geoff Keighley. It is not sufficient that they are getting made; additionally they want extra consideration, extra affect and the type of success that may encourage risk-averse, bigger studios to comply with go well with. 

Within the meantime, I assume I will simply fireplace up Morrowind once more.