notoriously-litigious-haptics-firm-tries-to-shakedown-valve

Valve is being sued by Immersion Company for allegedly infringing on seven patents relating to the touch know-how, or haptics, in its Steam Deck and Valve Index {hardware}. Immersion Company, based in 1993, is an organization that had an early historical past within the improvement of touchscreen know-how, together with a partnership with Microsoft, however from the 2000s onwards appears to have develop into an increasing number of litigious: To the extent it has been described as a “patent troll“. It claims to personal over 1,650 patents associated to haptics, and previously has sued Apple, Microsoft, Sony, and most not too long ago Meta Platforms.

Immersion Company describes itself as “the main developer and supplier of applied sciences for haptics” and has filed swimsuit in Washington district court docket. The swimsuit says Valve’s infringed seven of its patents and Immersion is trying to have it enjoined from additional infringement and, the essential half, “to recuperate an affordable royalty for such infringement”.

“Our mental property is related to lots of an important and cutting-edge methods wherein haptic know-how is and will be deployed, and, within the case of AR/VR experiences, haptics is essential to an immersive person expertise,” stated Eric Singer, chairman and CEO of Immersion.

“Whereas we’re happy to see that Valve acknowledges the worth of haptics and has adopted our haptic know-how in its handheld online game and AR/VR methods as a part of its effort to generate income streams by way of the gross sales of {hardware}, video games and different digital property, and commercials, it’s important for us to guard our enterprise towards infringement of our mental property to protect the investments that we’ve got made in our know-how,” stated Singer. 

The grievance asserts infringement of the next patents:

  • U.S. Patent No. 7,336,260: “Methodology and Equipment for Offering Tactile Sensations”
  • U.S. Patent No. 8,749,507: “Programs and Strategies for Adaptive Interpretation of Enter from a Contact-Delicate Enter System”
  • U.S. Patent No. 9,430,042: “Digital Detents By means of Vibrotactile Suggestions”
  • U.S. Patent No. 9,116,546: “System for Haptically Representing Sensor Enter”
  • U.S. Patent No. 10,627,907: “Place Management of a Person Enter Aspect Related With a Haptic Output System”
  • U.S. Patent No. 10,665,067: “Programs and Strategies for Integrating Haptics Overlay in Augmented Actuality”
  • U.S. Patent No. 11,175,738: “Programs and Strategies for Proximity-Primarily based Haptic Suggestions”

Apparently sufficient, Singer was appointed to his function in January this 12 months, changing lawyer Francis Jose. On the time Singer issued a press release discussing Immersion’s varied methods of delivering “shareholder worth” and particularly calls out “our focused litigation technique, together with however not restricted to our current lawsuit towards Meta Platforms”.

It’s value noting that Immersion has loved appreciable success through the years. A swimsuit towards Microsoft and Sony within the early 2000s resulted in an enormous win, with Microsoft opting to purchase 10% of Immersion to keep away from the combat whereas Sony took the corporate on and misplaced. It is even been speculated that the size of the loss on this case was what noticed the PlayStation 3 model of the Dualshock pad launch with out rumble.

I’ve requested Valve for remark, and can update with any response.