Bethesda Softworks has responded to allegations made final week by Doom Everlasting composer Mick Gordon, saying that Gordon “mischaracterized and misrepresented” the scenario “with a one-sided and unjust account of the information of the case.”

Issues between Gordon, an acclaimed composer with credit on a number of Bethesda video games and quite a few others, and Doom studio id Software program got here to mild in 2020 following the discharge of the Doom Everlasting OST. Gordon successfully disavowed it, saying he had not combined many of the tracks, and extra surprisingly predicted that he wouldn’t work with Bethesda once more sooner or later; a month later, Doom Everlasting government producer Marty Stratton posted an “open letter” on Reddit, shifting the blame onto Gordon and portraying him as unreliable and troublesome to work with.

Gordon remained silent on the matter till final week, when he shared a protracted and detailed assertion claiming that he was the goal of unfair and dishonest conduct on the a part of id, and particularly Stratton, who Gordon mentioned “lied concerning the circumstances surrounding the Doom Everlasting Soundtrack” and “used disinformation and innuendo” accountable him for its failure.

The ultimate straw got here, in response to Gordon, shortly after the discharge of the OST. He and Stratton had agreed on a path ahead, however just a few days later Stratton posted his open letter. Attorneys had been known as, proposals had been made and rejected, and finally Gordon went public to restore his popularity as a result of he felt there have been no different choices left.

“Utilizing NDAs, settlements and gag orders to silence truths is an appalling tactic utilized by individuals in excessive positions of energy petrified of accountability,” Gordon wrote. “I’m selecting to talk out as a result of the choice was to just accept that tactic as okay.”

Bethesda Softworks, the mum or dad firm of id Software program and writer of Doom Everlasting, rejected Gordon’s model of occasions outright in a press release launched at this time, nonetheless.

(Picture credit score: Bethesda Softworks)

“The latest submit by Mick Gordon each mischaracterized and misrepresented the group at id Software program, the event of Doom Everlasting, Marty Stratton, and Chad Mossholder with a one-sided and unjust account of an irreparable skilled relationship,” Bethesda mentioned. “We’re conscious of all the small print and historical past on this matter and unequivocally assist Marty, Chad, and the group at id Software program. We reject the distortion of the reality and selective presentation of incomplete ‘information.’ We stand prepared with full and full documented proof to reveal in an acceptable venue as wanted.”

Sarcastically, Bethesda mentioned that Gordon’s assertion has “incited harassment and threats” towards Stratton, Mossholder, and id Software program typically. Gordon made basically the identical allegation in his assertion final week, writing that “incidences of on-line abuse escalated at an alarming charge” after Stratton posted his missive on Reddit. Like Gordon, Bethesda known as on followers to chorus from attacking anybody concerned within the dispute, “together with Marty, Chad, or Mick,” however in contrast to Mick it additionally warned that harassment of its staff “will likely be met with swift and acceptable motion.”

“We stay extremely happy with id’s earlier collaborations with Mick Gordon and ask that followers chorus from reaching conclusions based mostly on his account,” Bethesda mentioned.

Mick Gordon performing the Doom soundtrack reside at The Game Awards 2016.

The response to Bethesda’s assertion on Twitter doesn’t appear to be broadly supportive. Some replies be aware that Gordon’s assertion was deep, detailed, and “introduced receipts,” whereas Bethesda’s response is a a lot briefer and easier denial; others introduced up the case of Bayonetta voice actor Helena Taylor, whose claims towards developer Platinum had been broadly supported earlier than they had been debunked. And naturally there are some (together with me) who simply want {that a} composer they actually like, and a studio they actually like, would please cease combating.

“Guys gotta sort things with Mick,” JS tweeted. “He’s a proficient creator and will undoubtedly return for the following Doom game. He’s a giant purpose that sequence is so extremely regarded.”

Sadly, that appears extraordinarily unlikely to occur. Gordon’s pre-Doom Everlasting relationship with id Software program and Bethesda was very fruitful: He contributed music to all of the Wolfenstein reboot video games—The New Order, The Previous Blood, The New Colossus, Youngblood, and Cyberpilot—and composed and produced the OSTs for the 2016 Doom reboot and Arkane’s 2017 immersive sim Prey. The Doom Everlasting soundtrack is nearly as good as any of them. However as we mentioned final week, it clearly induced a rift that is unlikely to heal anytime quickly, and Gordon’s prediction that he will not work with Bethesda once more appears very prone to come true.

I’ve reached out to Gordon for touch upon Bethesda’s response and can update if I obtain a reply.