Critical acclaim doesn’t always align with audience appreciation in the realm of cinema. Some films may be unfairly dismissed by critics, receiving low ratings that fail to capture the true essence of their entertainment value. Here are twelve movies with meager ratings that members of an online forum believe deserve better.

1. Hot Rod (2007)

Image Credit: Paramount Pictures.

Hot Rod is a delightful dose of hilarity that will have you in stitches from start to finish. Starring the talented Andy Samberg, this comedy follows Rod Kimble, an amateur stuntman with dreams of greatness. The unforgettable dialogues perfectly encapsulate its quirky humor, as pointed out by a member.

2. MacGruber (2010)

Image Credit: Universal Pictures.

Despite receiving lukewarm reviews, it has become a cult classic, beloved by fans for its absurd humor and over-the-top antics. A user shares that they will “defend it to death.” Another mentions this is their go-to film, and they’ve seen it no less than a hundred times. Will Forte’s portrayal of the bumbling yet oddly resourceful MacGruber is nothing short of comedic brilliance.

3. Under the Silver Lake (2018)

Image Credit: A24.

Despite its fifty-nine percent Rotten Tomatoes score, this enigmatic tale of a man searching for a missing woman in Los Angeles captivated the hearts of many. The film’s sprawling narrative and unexpected twists keep audiences on the edge of their seats. Director Robert Mitchell masterfully weaves a web of cryptic clues and eccentric characters, all tied together by Andrew Garfield’s captivating performance.

4. Spring Breakers (2012)

Image Credit: A24.

While it may not have been everyone’s cup of tea, this audacious film by Harmony Korine deserves a second look. Its bold approach and James Franco’s mesmerizing performance as the eccentric rapper alien delivers a unique experience that challenges conventional storytelling. Beneath its surface lies a thought-provoking commentary on youth culture and the pursuit of freedom.

5. Mission to Mars (2000)

Image Credit: Touchstone Pictures.

This film takes audiences on a thrilling interstellar journey fraught with danger and excitement. With its gripping story, stunning visuals, and talented cast, including Gary Sinise and Tim Robbins, the film offers a captivating ride through the vastness of space.

6. The Void (2016)

Image Credit: D Films.

For fans of horror John Carpenter, The Void is a hidden gem that channels his unique style. Although not directed by Carpenter, this Lovecraftian horror flick pays homage to the master filmmaker’s works. The film’s practical effects and eerie atmosphere take one back to classic horror movies.

7. Bullet Train (2022)

Image Credit: Sony Pictures.

Despite a 54% Rotten Tomatoes score, this thrill ride provided a cinematic masterpiece that has audiences cheering. Brad Pitt’s performance was charismatic and engaging, while the cleverly executed cameos added a playful touch. Sometimes critics fail to grasp the simple joy of an action-packed film experience, as evidenced by the higher audience score of 76%.

8. Horns (2013)

Image Credit: Dimension Films.

Based on the novel by Joe Hill, it is a dark and engaging supernatural thriller featuring a captivating performance by Daniel Radcliffe. Despite its forty-two percent rating on Rotten Tomatoes, this film offers a unique and intriguing premise. Radcliffe’s portrayal of a man accused of a heinous crime who begins to grow devil-like horns sets the stage for a gripping exploration of guilt, redemption, and the human psyche.

9. Vivarium (2019)

Image Credit: Vertigo Releasing.

This mind-bending and hauntingly memorable movie lingers in the mind long after the credits roll. With stellar performances from Imogen Poots and Jesse Eisenberg, the film takes viewers on an unsettling journey. Its exploration of suburban horror and existential dread is refreshingly original, making it a standout in the sci-fi thriller genre.

10. The Exorcist III (1990)

Image Credit: 20th Century Studios.

Often overshadowed by its iconic predecessor, The Exorcist III is a surprisingly effective horror film in its own right. Brad Dourif’s chilling performance elevates the film, keeping audiences engaged in the eerie tale of demonic possession.

11. Alien Resurrection (1997)

Image Credit: 20th Century Studios.

As the fourth installment in the beloved Alien franchise, Alien Resurrection had big shoes to fill and faced mixed reactions from critics. However, viewed as a standalone sci-fi film directed by Jean-Pierre Jeunet, it presents a visually stunning and quirky experience. Sigourney Weaver’s return as Ellen Ripley further brings out a captivating performance.

12. Ghost in the Shell (2017)

Image Credit: Paramount Pictures.

Based on the popular manga and anime franchise, this film faced a divisive reception upon its release. However, many fans appreciated the film’s dedication to honoring the source material with its stunning visual aesthetics. Scarlett Johansson’s portrayal of Major Motoko Kusanagi added depth to the character, while the film’s cyberpunk world provided an immersive experience.


Image Credit: Gramercy Pictures.
  • 15 Films With the Best Endings of All Time: Unforgettable Scenes That Changed Everything
  • 8 Controversial Comedies That Could Never Be Made Today